Sample report

See what a review looks like

A real RedlineBrief comparison: a services provider's MSA draft against the client's redline, reviewed from the provider's side. 38 changed clauses were surfaced; here are four of the eight critical ones.

65

Risk score / 100

8 critical · 5 moderate · 38 changed clauses

Executive summary

The counterparty's revisions shift risk heavily onto the provider: payment terms stretch from 30 to 90 days with late-payment interest and suspension rights removed; liability is capped at $10,000 for the client only; indemnification becomes one-sided; pre-existing IP is assigned to the client; termination for convenience drops to 5 days for the client while auto-renewal requires 180 days' notice; and a 24-month non-compete is added. These changes warrant careful negotiation.

§3.2 Invoices and payment terms

Critical
Invoices are due within thirty (30) days of the invoice date. Invoices are due within ninety (90) days after Client's approval of the invoice.

Why this matters

Extending payment from 30 to 90 days, and starting the clock only after the client approves the invoice, delays cash flow and lets payment slip indefinitely.

Suggested fallback redline

Invoices are due within thirty (30) days of the invoice date.

In the app: accept the fallback, keep their text, or write your own, then export everything as Track Changes into their Word file.

§8.1 Indemnification

Critical
Each party will defend and indemnify the other against third-party claims caused by its gross negligence, wilful misconduct or IP infringement. Provider will defend, indemnify and hold harmless Client and its affiliates against any and all claims, losses and expenses arising out of or relating to the Services or this Agreement.

Why this matters

A one-sided indemnity for "any and all claims arising out of the Services" makes the provider an insurer of the whole relationship, with no reciprocal protection.

Suggested fallback redline

Each party will defend, indemnify and hold harmless the other party against claims arising from its gross negligence, wilful misconduct, or infringement of a third party's intellectual property rights.

In the app: accept the fallback, keep their text, or write your own, then export everything as Track Changes into their Word file.

§9.1 Limitation of liability

Critical
Each party's total liability is limited to the fees paid or payable in the twelve (12) months before the claim. CLIENT'S TOTAL LIABILITY UNDER THIS AGREEMENT IS LIMITED TO TEN THOUSAND DOLLARS ($10,000).

Why this matters

The cap now protects only the client, at a token amount, while the provider's liability is uncapped.

Suggested fallback redline

Except for breach of confidentiality or indemnification obligations, each party's total liability under this Agreement is limited to the fees paid or payable in the twelve (12) months before the claim.

In the app: accept the fallback, keep their text, or write your own, then export everything as Track Changes into their Word file.

§5.1 Intellectual property assignment

Critical
Upon full payment, Provider assigns the Deliverables to Client, excluding Pre-Existing Materials, which Client may use under a licence. Provider assigns to Client all right, title and interest in the Deliverables, including any Pre-Existing Materials incorporated into them, effective upon creation.

Why this matters

Assigning the provider's pre-existing tools and templates, before payment, would stop it reusing its own know-how for other clients.

Suggested fallback redline

Upon full payment, Provider assigns to Client all right, title and interest in the Deliverables, excluding Pre-Existing Materials. Provider grants Client a non-exclusive, perpetual, royalty-free licence to use Pre-Existing Materials incorporated into the Deliverables.

In the app: accept the fallback, keep their text, or write your own, then export everything as Track Changes into their Word file.

Try it on your own contracts

Create an account and run the free sample yourself, or upload your own draft and their redline. Free credits included.

Start free

The sample contracts are fictional. RedlineBrief provides decision support, not legal advice.